Offering a new framework for male confidence
Words: Jack Byassee | Design: Reese Modugno

I used to lie to myself and say that my younger brother wasn’t the bigger and stronger one of the two of us.

I’d stand a little taller in family pictures, scramble for excuses when friends would ask us to stand back-to-back for a height-off, and dodge one-on ones on the basketball court under the guise of not caring enough. My role as the older brother became a contest I couldn’t seem to win. As a defense mechanism for my preteen manhood, I opted for denial.

But when I look back now, I wonder — why did I care this much?

Being young accounts for a lot here. From a young age, I have noticed other guys my age doing the same self-protective things. I see them cover their eyes or blink rapidly after hurting themselves to not be seen crying. Or, they insist they aren’t into the new girly pop songs to shield their egos. I do these things, too. Proving you meet the bill of ideal masculinity is a constant battle in the sea of male socialization. We can’t blame ourselves for feeling this way. Instead, we should hold the societal standards of manhood responsible. From a young age, boys are told to “man up,” “be strong,” “don’t show weakness,” “don’t let them see you waiver.”

“[As] men, just naturally, especially younger men, you look for a mentor, you look for a guide,” says Josh Brewster, a Clinical Social Worker and Therapist based in Saint Paul, Minnesota. “How are you going to mold yourself? … That’s part of the maturing process … [developing] a vision for yourself.”

From Independence to Interdependence

Guidance comes from peers and the male authority figures in our lives, but even they only know so much. We’re asked to meet a checklist of expectations — be strong, independent, fearless, invulnerable. But if we don’t challenge these notions, we won’t get the benefits from deeper connections.

There are countless times I’ve formed an armor of ‘confidence’ by adhering to masculine norms. In group settings dominated by men, I’ve found myself tailoring my presence to what was expected of me — my body language, facial expressions, style of speaking, the sorts of jokes I’m telling. I might’ve outwardly projected something resembling confidence, but it was built upon standards that made me lose myself.

We need others to help us be genuine people, rather than using them to separate ourselves further. This can mean offering a shoulder to cry on, but also a guiding hand to call us out when we slip up. What’s important is that vulnerability comes from both sides of the relationship.

“Men are often raised in society to be intrapersonal,” says Tyler Jacobs Lewis, a counselor with the Broadlawns Community Clinic in Des Moines, Iowa.

“[Being] primarily intrapersonal in a relationship with another person is not compatible with healthy relationships because you’re thinking about yourself first instead of putting you both on an equal footing.”

Rigid norms of masculinity confine men to minimal outlets for emotional expression.

“Society will [skew] masculinity in all one direction, and sometimes in a very unhealthy sort of way,” says Pat McArtor, a mental health counselor based in Iowa City. “If you’re talking [about] masculinity, you have to talk about the other aspects of human beings as well.”

Photo by Jasmin Höger on Unsplash

When you’re raised to idolize power, strength, and independence over emotional depth, you forfeit a substantial amount of your humanity. When we are demanded to be stronger and keep our guards up, it instills suppression rather than leading to growth.

“In a society that values individual initiatives and success, men internalize the message: it’s all about them and their aims,” Jacobs-Lewis says.

Living Up to Impossible Standards

However, we are beginning to accept more open minding and diverse modes of male expression. Though while exploring this newfound diversity, there are also new pressures that challenge our self-confidence.

“[I] think that we’re affected, confidence wise, a lot more than other generations, because we have more pathways into being brought down,” says Joseph Egan, a 20-year-old from Vancouver, Canada. “If we see people [who] are at least pretending to be confident and pretending to have everything … [we start to think] ‘everybody has it except for me,’ when in reality nobody really has it.”

We grew up in a cyber-centric landscape that creates impossible standards — anyone can post their highlights like everyday realities. People are pressured to present a facade of success and superiority. In this digital age, we need ways to come back to validate ourselves offline.

“Don’t listen to social media [for guidance],” McArtor says. “Go to folks that have done work in this area and would be able to explain it, because it gets skewed so much.”

Building Confidence

Podcasters who claim to know the secret behind masculinity can’t teach you how to be confident. Instead of seeking validation from people with no background, Dr. Scott Liu, a staff psychologist for the University of Iowa Counseling Service, suggests thinking of growing self-confidence as like building a house.

“[You] have to lay the good foundation and then you start building the house on top of it,” Liu says. “Confidence [comes] from within, I think that’s the major foundation of your self-perception.”

Think of external validation as the decoration. Your foundation is who you are, and the decor will collect overtime as you build healthy relationships.

“Everything else, like your grades, your sports, your report cards, your supervisor saying, ‘Good job,’ or your professor saying, ‘Hey, that’s a really good paper,’ — will be like a decoration,” Liu says.

Internally-sourced confidence doesn’t need to be proven. I’ve noticed the moments when I’m loudest are the times I’m trying to hide something I feel insecure about. I find myself wanting protection from the quiet times that leave me vulnerable. But if you confidently choose to be quiet and vulnerable, you can open yourself up to judgment without allowing it to tear you down.

If we follow the tried-and-untrue instructions for male performance, we volunteer to lose a lot of ourselves.
When we conform to outdated norms, we limit who we can be.

How do we break free?

Standards of masculinity are deeply embedded in our social fabric, so how do we break free? It requires critical examination of our behaviors and willingness to adjust them — which can be incredibly daunting.

“Does someone not like my behavior and how it impacts them? Is it stemming from how I’ve been told I should be? Do I not like another guy’s concept of manliness? Do I see how it’s impacting his relationships to be intrapersonal and not think about others?” Jacob-Lewis says. “I was able to ask these questions when I started having conversations with women and longtime friends about what they saw from me instead of just going with my own self-evaluation or self-inquiry.”

These questions are directed to the boy who was told to suppress his emotions to boost his ego. If this is you, I hope you second-guess yourself next time you seek confidence in the wrong places, and open up to a new definition of masculinity.

I think I cared so much about fulfilling the roles of a brother and man because I feared I would lose the
respect of my peers if I didn’t. But I’ve learned that being your sincere and authentic self, independent of expectation, merits greater respect.

What is sold as confidence is fundamentally disconnected from fulfillment, satisfaction, and happiness. Behaving counter to those norms is hard because you’re risking shame and ostracization. But by breaking down these barriers, we can live more fully as ourselves.

We can live a version of confidence that we can call our own.

No responses yet

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

css.php