There’s Some Things A Computer Just Can’t Do


Think of an artist. Think of their tools. What do you picture? Easel? Brushes? A camera? Not necessarily. 

It’s 2025, and as technology redefines reality, so does our understanding of “art.” For some creatives, starting the artistic process today merely means grabbing a laptop and diving into artificial intelligence software prompting.

In 2022, AI as we know it took center stage. Now, AI chatbots have taken the world by storm. Images, videos, audio, and text can readily be made in seconds with AI generators like DALL-E, Sora, and ChatGPT. These impressive tech developments demand a reassessment of the value and future of art.

AI Functionality

Before digging in, it’s crucial to understand the engine. AI art generators use a Large Language Model, which pulls data from all across the internet. The models then apply learned patterns to put together an output based on the user’s prompt. 

While some find the outputs aesthetically pleasing and accessible, others think the resulting product is a lazy regurgitation. Critics argue that anything new that AI creates are just stolen, repackaged material since any and all AI creations depend on preexisting artwork.

Lawyer Devin Owens says current intellectual property frameworks weren’t made with AI language models in mind.

“Technology drives law, not the other way around,” Owens says. “Society is going to adapt to the technology because it has no choice.” 

The legal mess of AI ownership only escalates as people profit from AI-generated content. This ranges from generating streaming music, to selling t-shirts or notebooks with AI graphics.

But for freelance artist Meghavi Patel, who makes her living from acrylic paintings, the professional art world just looks different, not entirely bleak.

“When I started [my art career] in 2014, the digital market was booming,” Patel says. “But now it’s the other way around: There’s a higher demand for [the] handmade.”

With AI art flooding the digital art market, handmade art’s value will persist for its unique qualities of imperfection, authenticity, and human connection, Patel says. 

“Art is when I get to express my emotions. This is my passion,” Patel says. “When my mind is confused or I want to do something, when I’m disappointed, this is the way I can express my feelings.”

She approaches her own work by carefully considering the intimate, human clues to make the piece more meaningful.

Amy Kim, assistant professor of photography at Hope College, says AI use is “here to stay.” She believes the value of AI art will likely decrease as the supply begins to outweigh the demand, and hopes that the overwhelming amount of AI art will enhance the public’s appreciation for the time-consuming, critical processes of human-made artwork. 

The Value of Art

Artist and art educator, Dr. Jim O’Donnell, is more skeptical.

“[AI] can be a useful tool, but it has to be ethical,” O’Donnell says. “A lot of artists are suffering right now.” 

He notes that the freer the society, the more art there is. O’Donnell’s students often ask him, ‘What’s the point? What’s the value in this?’ 

O’Donnell’s answer? “You’re being human. This is a human thing.”

However, community support for real artistry is still very much needed.

“If there’s no policy and legal changes, if artists don’t win lawsuits … I think we’re all in a lot of trouble,” O’Donnell says.

Ironically, for creatives like O’Donnell, the very questions AI brings upon the art world prompts existential coping that generates … art. 

“At the end of the day, all I can do is open my little sketchbook,” O’Donnell says. “Like so many humans through history, I deal with that existential crisis by putting my hand on a pencil, on paper, and making something.”

Words: Lily Fleming 

No responses yet

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

css.php